Orchestre de Paris / Philippe Jordan by Schubert, Bruckner, -tól (2023/2023), Karmester Philippe Jordan, Philharmonie de Paris, Paris, France

Placing the orchestra in the spotlight, these two incomplete masterpieces—by Schubert and Bruckner—illustrate the Romantic symphony’s debt to the Germanic tradition. A sombre motif in the low strings, a plaintive oboe melody: from the opening bars, the ‘Unfinished’ Symphony draws us into Schubertian mystery, where song turns dramatic, penetrated by desolation verging on terror. Left with only two movements—the second more soothing than the first—this incomplete work is anything but unaccomplished, standing as one of the pinnacles of musical romanticism. In counterpoint, what better reply than Bruckner’s Ninth, which the ailing composer was unable to finish? Of this opus dedicated to ‘dem lieben Gott’ (‘to the good Lord’), we have three movements: the ‘solemn and mysterious’ first, where the tension is carried by imperious horns; the hammering second, like a Dantean race to the abyss, reminiscent of Stravinsky; and then a concluding, testamentary Adagio, including a chorale under which the composer noted ‘Abschied vom Leben’ (‘Farewell to life’). Whether it reflects the anguish of a dying man or the trusting resignation of one placing himself in the hands of his creator, is up to each listener to decide.