Past Production Reviews
7Vocally, there was a great deal to admire. The opera can hardly be considered anyone’s favourite Verdi, but is certainly a fine vehicle for Verdian voices. Christian Gerhaher, best known for Schubert Lieder and modern works, sang the role for the first time last year, and I felt that – fine as a singer he undoubtedly is – he is not quite right for Simon. Tézier’s rich, deep voice is, however, simply perfect for the role, and each note a feast for the ears. Gerhaher may be the more nuanced actor, but give me the voice each time. Jennifer Rowley continued to impress as Amelia after a slightly bumpy start – top notes spot on. Christof Fischesser was in very fine voice, his low notes always something to look forward to. The strong baritone of Nicholas Brownlee as Paolo added to the excellent vocal mix. Brent Michael Smith as Pietro was a firm bass. The sextet at the end of Act I was glorious.
Marco Armiliato led the Philharmonia Zürich in a very energetic rendition, at times with a heavy hand. This was especially noticeable in the cavatina of the soprano “Come in quest’ora bruna”, where the orchestra “rolls”, imitating the waves of the sea. Here, the result was more a train running over the delicate, sweet rendition of Jennifer Rowley (Amelia). Globally, however, the orchestra was exciting and engaging, with sweeping phrasing and remarkable brass sound.
Liparit Avetisyan was heroic in his limping on the side of the stage, but the obvious pain he was in didn’t hinder his performance. His tenor was youthful and enthusiastic, with bold high notes, a bit on the boisterous side, which doesn’t hurt, in this role. In the other “minor” roles, I want to mention Nadezhda Karyazina as Maddalena, whose deep, strong mezzo really made an impression, and provided a proper foundation for the wonderful Act 4 quartet “Bella figlia dell’amore”.
An allererster Stelle sei hier das Debut von Hanna-Elisabeth Müller als Arabella genannt. Was für eine wunderschöne facettenreiche Stimme. Auch schauspielerisch gestaltete sie ihre Partie sehr überzeugend. Gewiss wird Arabella eine ihrer Glanzpartien werden. Ein Genuss! Zum ersten Mal an diesem Hause hörte man in der Rolle der Zdenka die Sopranistin Anett Fritsch. Sie gestaltete diese Partie mit höhensicherer Stimme und viel Energie. Die fast unsingbare Rolle der Fiakermilli war mit der temperamentvollen Aleksandra Kubas-Kruk gut besetzt. Sie meisterte die Koloraturen souverän. Die Partie der besorgten Mutter Adelaide war bei Judith Schmid bestens aufgehoben. Die Kartenauflegerin gestaltete Irène Friedli.
In Gideon Davey's unified set - the lobby of a four-story Viennese hotel with balustrades - the colors red and black of the Reich, predominate. An art deco chandelier dangles from the stage tower, completing the evocation of the zeitgeist. Arabella's three suitors are dressed in the uniform of the SS. It makes perfect sense, then, to see in the closing bars a Nazi mob violently question the happy-ending of Strauss's opera, by pointing guns to Mandryka, the Croatian outsider and love rival of the officers. The zeitgeist will break into the play by three other occasions. Two banners with swastikas can be seen along either side of the stage during the ball of the second act. The Fiakermilli, mouthpiece of the vox populi, dressed in a folkish dirndl plays a pantomime with young peasants. Aleksandra Kubas-Kruk adds her yodeling coloratura effectively. The scenic highlight is reserved for the interlude that normally comments on Zdenka and Matteo's love night but is here enlivened by Philippe Giraudeau's choreography as a street fight between brown shirts and young peasants wearing lederhosen.
At the second of four performances, Pascale Spinney displayed a silken, dark-hued mezzo as Léonor, and acted the role with clarity and poise. Her moving rendition of “O mon Fernand,” the score’s best-known lament, earned deserved cheers from the capacity crowd.
